Authored answer and judgement fixtures; no model responses or human-rating study
Coverage: 6 graded of 8 candidates; 2 pending
Completed rubric decisions: accepted=3; rejected=3
complete: accepted
paraphrase: accepted
negation: accepted
unsupported-guarantee: rejected (support)
missing-verification: rejected (verification)
wrong-command: rejected (command, support)
uncertain-wording: pending (missing or uncertain criterion judgement)
not-reviewed: pending (no authored review fixture)
Pending judgements remain outside the scored subset and visible in coverage.
Quote matching validates excerpts; semantic ratings are supplied judgements.